OESF Portables Forum

Model Specific Forums => Gemini PDA => Gemini PDA - General Discussion => Topic started by: Pete G. on November 23, 2019, 09:36:10 pm

Title: Sudden slow charging
Post by: Pete G. on November 23, 2019, 09:36:10 pm
Has this happened to anyone else?  Usually my fast-charging Gemini comes up to full in a couple of hours, but today I came back after about four hours and the LED was still red!  The status panel said "Approx 4 hours left" and "50%" !  I unplugged the USB, and replugged it (reversing the connector for good measure). A little while later it was up to 72% and has since been charging at the normal speed.

I'd guess that there is some pin in the connector or something that indicates fast charging, which somehow hadn't made contact.  Does anybody know what the protocol is?
Title: Sudden slow charging
Post by: gymbo on November 24, 2019, 12:20:15 pm
Quote from: Pete G.
Has this happened to anyone else?  Usually my fast-charging Gemini comes up to full in a couple of hours, but today I came back after about four hours and the LED was still red!  The status panel said "Approx 4 hours left" and "50%" !  I unplugged the USB, and replugged it (reversing the connector for good measure). A little while later it was up to 72% and has since been charging at the normal speed.

I'd guess that there is some pin in the connector or something that indicates fast charging, which somehow hadn't made contact.  Does anybody know what the protocol is?
For me, slow charging just appears randomly once in a while (I usually charge it over night, so might be slow charging more often then I actually observe). Usually unplugging and plugging in again solves the "issue", but I have seen no particular reason WHY it happens. Only thing I can think of, is that it is related to the somewhat strange behavior , where it suddenly shuts off at different battery levels. I.e. that there is some problem with power-management in general on the Gemini...

Whatever the reason, hope it is fixed on the Cosmo...
Title: Sudden slow charging
Post by: Daniel W on November 24, 2019, 03:08:05 pm
Quote from: Pete G.
Has this happened to anyone else?
For me, fast charging my Gemini has always been a bit hit and miss. When it doesn't kick in, as Gymbo said, unplugging and reconnecting the charger usually works.

Quote from: Pete G.
...the status panel said "Approx 4 hours left" and "50%" ! I unplugged the USB, and replugged it...
Since I mostly use my Gemini at home, I've never used a lock screen, so I didn't know it could show the estimated remaining time until charged, but, well.. after a while, it does, before which it just says "charging", so I've learned something today. Thank you.

Quote from: Pete G.
I'd guess that there is some pin in the connector or something that indicates fast charging, which somehow hadn't made contact. Does anybody know what the protocol is?
It's more involved than a pin for on or off. The "Pump Express" protocol by MediaTek doesn't seem widely documented, but I did find this (from 2016): http://cdn-cw.mediatek.com/Features/Pump%2...ntroduction.pdf (http://cdn-cw.mediatek.com/Features/Pump%20Express%20Series%20Introduction.pdf)

Basically, the Gemini sends a sequence of carefully timed pulses to request a particular voltage. As far as I understand, they are sent via the same pins as the actual power, so I'd guess it's more a matter of timing glitches than bad connections, which begs the question: is it the Gemini or the charger that doesn't behave reliably? That's perhaps something someone with access to multiple Geminis and chargers could look into.

According to the document linked above, Pump Express 2.0 and 3.0 (also, reasonably 4.0, from 2018) supports stepping the voltage in fine increments, but the Gemini power brick just says 5/7/9/12V and, using a USB-C power meter, I've only observed voltages close to 5Volt or 9Volt. That would suggest Pump Express+ (version 1.0) which this blog https://hasbrouck.org/blog/archives/2018_10.html (https://hasbrouck.org/blog/archives/2018_10.html) seems to agree with.
Title: Sudden slow charging
Post by: Pete G. on November 25, 2019, 02:46:06 am
Quote from: Daniel W
Since I mostly use my Gemini at home, I've never used a lock screen, so I didn't know it could show the estimated remaining time until charged, but, well.. after a while, it does, before which it just says "charging", so I've learned something today. Thank you.
"lock screen"?   Not sure what you mean, there.  I never lock my unit, as I try to keep it close!  I get the battery status panel by swiping down from the top of the screen, and tapping the battery icon in the panel that appears.

Quote from: Daniel W
Basically, the Gemini sends a sequence of carefully timed pulses to request a particular voltage. As far as I understand, they are sent via the same pins as the actual power, so I'd guess it's more a matter of timing glitches than bad connections, which begs the question: is it the Gemini or the charger that doesn't behave reliably? That's perhaps something someone with access to multiple Geminis and chargers could look into.
Ahh, thanks...  That makes sense -- and sounds like lots of opportunities for things to go wrong!

Thanks for all that info.  I'll have to dig.
Title: Sudden slow charging
Post by: Daniel W on November 25, 2019, 10:44:56 am
Quote from: Pete G.
"lock screen"? Not sure what you mean, there. I never lock my unit, as I try to keep it close! I get the battery status panel by swiping down from the top of the screen, and tapping the battery icon in the panel that appears.
When plugging in the charger, the Gemini needs some time to figure out the remaining time estimate, and I didn't wait long enough. By the time I tried using a lock screen, the estimate was available, and I failed to realize that, by then, it would ALSO have been visible on the status panel, as well as in the main settings menu. So, now I know three ways to check it, two of which does not require a lock screen, which is nice, as I currently keep next to nothing sensitive on my Gemini anyway.
Title: Sudden slow charging
Post by: gidds on November 26, 2019, 06:39:23 pm
I'm surprised more people haven't considered the advantages of slow-charging:I've got into the routine of plugging my Gemini in when I put it down on my bedside table and go to sleep; it's always charged when I wake, and always lasts the day.

Of course, everyone's lifestyle is different; but there's at least a chance that I'm not the only one it's ideal for…