the biggest nightmare I had once was when I wanted to reinstall my computer - it had a pair of 80GB drive, one newer than the other, manually mirrored.
I set the newer 80GB drive as primary, disconnected the old main system drive, installed dual-boot linux and windows on the new drive, got it all patched up.
Reconnected the old drive as slave, moving the jumpers across. The old drive was corrupted! No partitions found, And I'd just wiped the only backup! Panic!
It was late, and rather than trying to run recovery programs, I went to bed. In the morning, on a hunch, I took out the new drive, set the old one back as master, and PHEW! Everything intact.
Tho' the drives were VERY similar, the jumper positions were different and I'd accidentally set a jumper on the old drive which set it to 32GB mode for old bioses, which meant all the data appeared scrambled.
That taught me two lessons. First, never, even if it's only for a very short while, rely on a single hard disk to store all your data (if I'd run a recovery utility, it'd have wiped EVERYTHING forever). Second, DON'T panic and run a recovery utility, reverse everything you did and put the system back to what it was before assuming that a drive is corrupt. Third, that the data on a hard drive is worth far more than the drive itself. Fourth, that I can't count